American Idiot Is Not A Show For Everyone REVIEW -
Adalita, Phil Jamieson and Sarah McLeod share the roll of St Jimmy in American Idiot the Musical. Photo by Ros O'Gorman

Adalita, Phil Jamieson and Sarah McLeod share the roll of St Jimmy in Green Day's American Idiot. Photo by Ros O'Gorman

American Idiot Is Not A Show For Everyone REVIEW

by Paul Cashmere on March 1, 2018

in News

I just didn’t get American Idiot. Is the background on this show based on Mel Brooks ‘The Producers’, about a company that tries to make money by producing a sure-fire flop … but then it takes off?

The premise of creating a theatre production around a Green Day album featuring depressing content about George W. Bush and the Iraq War seems too Mel Brooksish to be true. But it is.

Bush, at least, has been updated to Trump for relevance but the entire show is just so damn depressing. I can’t work out who would enjoy this show. Theatre fans won’t grasp the Green Day theme, Green Day fans will be hard-pressed to understand the dance moves. Remember when Pink Floyd called one of their compilation albums ‘A Collection of Great Dance Songs’? At least that was meant to be a joke.

Green Day's American Idiot. Photo by Ros O'Gorman

I can only assume this show will appeal mainly to people who don’t know Green Day and rarely go to the theatre. At least then they won’t make comparisons.

‘American Idiot’ is the Green Day equivalent to Pink Floyd’s ‘The Wall’. To take that to a wider audience Roger Waters adapted it into a movie.

Green Day's American Idiot. Photo by Ros O'Gorman

This is technically a Rock Opera, not a Musical. A Musical features dialogue and song, a Play is just dialogue and an Opera is music. Dialogue is minimal in this show, used mainly for continuity.

The plot revolves around three down-trodden youths who want to want to escape their suburban dead-end. Along the way, they detour through a world of sex, drugs and rock and roll. Some might see similarities to the life of the shows creator Billie Joe Armstrong but unlike the life of Armstrong, none of them end up as world famous, millionaire rock stars at the end.

Green Day's American Idiot. Photo by Ros O'Gorman

The Australian production features real rock stars Phil Jamieson, Adalita and Sarah McLeod rotating on various nights in the role of drug dealer St Jimmy. Their presence is definitely a drawcard. Jamieson was on-call for opening night. He channels his years as Grinspoon frontman into the character to own the stage and project throughout the room.

Green Day's American Idiot. Photo by Ros O'Gorman

The real pressure is on Ben Bennett as Johnny, who took over the role only yesterday after the sudden sacking of Linden Furnell for alleged misconduct.

Green Day's American Idiot. Photo by Ros O'Gorman

Connor Crawford plays Tunny, whose life takes a turn when he decides to go into the army, is wounded and has a leg amputated. Alex Jeans plays the third character Will, who plans on leaving town with Johnny and Tunny until he discovers his girlfriend is pregnant and stays behind.

They star alongside Kaylah Attard as Tunny’s nurse Extraordinary Girl, Phoebe Panaaretos as Whatsername, who befriends Johnny and starts the destruction of her own life and Ashleigh Taylor is Heather, Will’s pregnant girlfriend.

Green Day's American Idiot. Photo by Ros O'Gorman

These six actors do a remarkable job holding a difficult plot together.

Maybe I am missing something. The original U.S. production did quite well and picked up a Tony nomination for Best Musical. This one really falls into the ‘alt-theatre’ category.

Green Day's American Idiot. Photo by Ros O'Gorman

Regardless, Melbourne is once again crowned the Arts Capital of Australia with so many world-class productions running simultaneously. With ‘Beautiful: The Carole King Musical’ across the road from ‘American Idiot’ and ‘Priscilla Queen of the Desert’ playing just around the corner, Melbourne really stands alongside New York and London for major productions.

‘American Idiot’ will appeal to some people. If you liked ‘Beautiful’ or ‘Priscilla’, I doubt it will be for you.

American Idiot’ will play at Melbourne’s Comedy Theatre until 11 March 2018.

Listen to the Noise11 Music News channel now at iHeartRadio



Related Posts

Whitfield Crane
Whitfield Crane Talks Travelling, Touring and Creating

Whitfield Crane's scene is a creative minefield of radness. The Ugly Kid Joe frontman's scene is still as incessant as it was when he answered this question two years ago: “My scene is a lot of movement, a lot of travelling, a backpack, a credit card, a passport, an accountant, no responsibilities, no debt, fun, hedonism, music, surf, sand, snowboard and adventure.” Presently, tennis and orchestras are at the forefront of his scene. In particular, Australian tennis legend Pat Cash, and Crane's very own Orchestra of Doom.

4 hours ago
Noel Gallagher of Oasis, Noise11, Photo
What’s The Story Morning Glory with Liam and Noel’s Oasis Songs at Solo Shows?

With both sort of Gallaghers, Liam and Noel, touring Australia in November and December, Oasis fans are pretty much guaranteed an Oasis setlist between the two shows.

9 hours ago
Solange to play four Sydney Opera House dates

Solange is taking on a four-night residency at Australia's iconic Sydney Opera House in January.

2 days ago
Robbie Williams Heavy Entertainment Tour at Rod Laver Arena on Saturday 24 February 2018. Photo by Ros O'Gorman
Robbie Williams teases new music

Robbie Williams took to social media to share a black and white photo of himself back in the studio, leading fans to speculate he might be working on a Christmas album.

2 days ago
Foo Fighters plan new album for 2020

Foo Fighters drummer Taylor Hawkins has confirmed the group "should" drop their 10th studio album by 2020, and revealed frontman Dave Grohl has "a lot of demos" he has worked on.

2 days ago
Ella Hooper photo by Ros O'Gorman
Daily Mail Writer Goes Batshit Crazy With Ella Hooper Story

Is Daily Mail writer Candice Jackson stark raving mad or is the Daily Mail just full of hack writers who lack common decency?

2 days ago
Ben Folds photo by Ros O'Gorman
Ben Folds to reunite with his former band the Melbourne Symphony Orchestra

Ben Folds will perform again with the Melbourne Symphony Orchestra in 2020.

2 days ago