David Gilmour Says What Went Wrong With Momentary Lapse Of Reason In Pink Floyd Podcast - Noise11.com
Pink Floyd The Later Years

Pink Floyd The Later Years

David Gilmour Says What Went Wrong With Momentary Lapse Of Reason In Pink Floyd Podcast

by Paul Cashmere on November 26, 2019

in News

Pink Floyd have debuted the first of a four-part series of podcasts with David Gilmour in conversation with BBC Radio’s Matt Everitt ahead of the release of the Pink Floyd The Later Years box set.

The Later Years combines all of the post-Roger Waters Pink Floyd recordings with previously unreleased live recordings and outtakes from ‘A Momentary Lapse of Reason’ and ‘The Division Bell’.

In episode one Gilmour talks about the departure of Roger Waters and the faults he hears now in the first non-Waters album ‘A Momentary Lapse of Reason’. ‘It’s a difficult thing to discuss. It is a painful thing for all of us to discuss. Roger’s departure had damaged people. I talked about it at the time. Its very tricky,” Gilmour tells Everitt.

About the album he says, “We got to Los Angeles and pretty up to that moment we had used clicktracks and drum machines. We started in Los Angeles by adding drums to these tracks and it was really coming together. We had the good songs, we had ‘Learning to Fly’, ‘On The Turning Away’, ‘Sorrow’, for me those were the big moments. Rick was coming in and working sometimes, Nick was there but there were difficulties”.

Gilmour, Mason and Wright were like kids in the studio with all the new toys to play with and that, David says, is where they went wrong. “The thing about the time was that there was a mass of new technology, new keyboards, synthesizers. We were keen to make a record that was of its time. We embraced the new technology with enthusiasm. That was a fashion and fashions go out of fashion. I think in the years after ‘Momentary Lapse Of Reason’ there were times when I felt we hadn’t followed the timeless template that we should have done at that time. I think we wanted to go back, temper down some of those things, replace some of those jangly keyboards with nicer Hammond organ. That’s what we’ve been doing in the recent past. We got Nick to come and play the drums on every track. We found old takes of Rick playing Hammond organ which for some reason we didn’t use at the time. We had a clear idea of what we were doing and how we wanted it to sound but years later you realize that it was the 80s”.

Listen to Episode one of the Pink Floyd podcast.

*THE LATER YEARS* Included on ‘The Later Years’, a 16-disc box set (5xCDs, 6xBlu-Rays, 5xDVDs) covering the material created by David Gilmour, Nick Mason and Richard Wright from 1987 onwards, with unreleased audio and audiovisual material, including the 1989 Venice and 1990 Knebworth concerts, as well as updated, restored and remixed audio and video, 2 x 7” singles, 60-page hardback Photo Book, 40-page hardback Credits Book, Lyrics Book, 3 x reproduction tour programmes, card envelope containing collectible memorabilia, plus Blu-rays and DVDs in individual wallets. Release date is 13 December 2019, with a 12-track ‘Highlights’ package (2-LP or 1-CD) available on 29 November 2019.

Noise11 on Instagram

You’ll discover music news first following Noise11 on Twitter

Comment on the news of the day, join Noise11 on Facebook

Noise11.com

Related Posts

The Beatles Anthology box 2025 vinyl edition
The Beatles’ Lost Epic The Unreleased Story of Carnival of Light Once Again Fails To Surface on Anthology

There is one Beatles song that has taken on mythical status among fans, collectors and music historians. It has never been released, never leaked, and exists only in the archives of Abbey Road Studios. It is called Carnival of Light.

1 day ago
Mavis Staples to Release New Album ‘Sad And Beautiful World’ November 7

There are few voices in American music that carry the weight of history, faith, and resilience quite like Mavis Staples. Now 86, Staples is still moving forward with the same passion that has defined her life in music, announcing the release of her new album Sad And Beautiful World for November 7. Produced by Brad Cook (Bon Iver, Waxahatchee, Nathaniel Rateliff), the record is a sweeping celebration of survival and connection, featuring appearances from some of music’s greatest names.

2 days ago
Jimi Hendrix Band of Gypsys
Jimi Hendrix’s New York: A Gritty, Intimate Portrait of the Guitar God’s East Coast Awakening

A fresh and intimate window into Jimi Hendrix’s New York chapter has arrived with the nine-minute short film Jimi Hendrix’s New York, a companion piece to the expansive Electric Lady Studios: A Jimi Hendrix Vision deluxe box set.

3 days ago
The Doors Live At Bakersfield
The Doors: Live in Bakersfield, August 21, 1970 — A Wild, Rare Live Release

The Doors’ newly issued Live in Bakersfield, August 21, 1970 is one of the most compelling live documents to surface from the band’s archives in years. Released on both CD and limited edition vinyl, the concert captures Jim Morrison, Ray Manzarek, Robby Krieger, and John Densmore in a unique and unpredictable setting.

3 days ago
The Who, Pete Townshend. Photo by Ros O'Gorman
Pete Townshend: Reveling at 80 on Final Who Tour and Bold New Beginnings

London’s indefatigable rock sage Pete Townshend recently granted AARP The Magazine a deeply revealing interview, with the questioning prowess of Jim Sullivan guiding him through reflections on The Who’s swan song and his exhilarating future ahead.

4 days ago
The Beatles Anthology box 2025 vinyl edition
The Beatles’ Anthology 4 Announcement Splits Fans Between Celebration and Criticism

The Beatles’ world lit up on 21 August 2025 when Apple Corps confirmed what had long been whispered: Anthology 4will arrive this November as part of a deluxe 8-CD / 12-LP box set. For many, the announcement was nothing short of historic—a long-awaited continuation of the celebrated mid-’90s Anthology trilogy. But while excitement has been intense, the news has also stirred division among fans. Some see Anthology 4 as a fitting final chapter, while others accuse it of being an unnecessary cash-grab.

4 days ago
Rolling Stones No 2
Rolling Stones Songs That Have Never Been Performed Live

It is Sunday afternoon in Australia so just for a bit of fun, he is a list of all of the Rolling Stones have recorded but have never performed live.

5 days ago