Fact: The Pretty Things ‘SF Sorrow’ Was The First Rock Opera, Tommy Was Second - Noise11.com
Pretty Things SF Sorrow

Pretty Things SF Sorrow

Fact: The Pretty Things ‘SF Sorrow’ Was The First Rock Opera, Tommy Was Second

by Paul Cashmere on September 12, 2018

in News

Pretty Things rock opera ‘SF Sorrow’ album predates The Who’s ‘Tommy’ by six months but to this day Pete Townshend has not cited The Pretty Things classic as an inspiration.

“The real fact of the matter is that I have never heard that, not that he copied it, but he admired it,” says founding Pretty Things member and bass player Dick Taylor. “There are plenty of people who have told me that Pete has said a lot of time “that was a great album and a inspiration.” That is hearsay. I haven’t heard him say it myself”.

While Townshend hasn’t credited ‘SF Sorrow’ as an inspiration Taylor says that he once threatened legal action if they said it inspired Tommy. “When we played ‘SF Sorrow’ at the Royal Albert Hall in London, Phil (May) got a letter from Pete Townshend and opened it. He went “how nice”. It was letter saying “good luck chaps”. But then he said, because Phil had said he said it was an inspiration because it was common knowledge he said that, the letter went on to say basically “Good luck, but to my knowledge I have never heard ‘SF Sorrow’ so please desist from saying it inspired Tommy or otherwise I will reach for my lawyer’.”

Taylor said that regardless, they went on with the show. “It was upsetting. Poor Phil, it was a nice letter, oh God. It really put a bit of a downer on the experience but we still went on and did a good show”.

Despite the album being released in 1968, Pretty Things did not perform the rock opera as a complete piece until 30 years later in 1998. “We did in in 1998 live at Abbey Road Studios,” Dick said. “We assembled most of the band who played on ‘SF Sorrow’. We talked about whether it was feasible to do it. We did it with Arthur Brown doing the narrating and David Gilmour doing the guitar bits. We did it one more time with Arthur and David and then several times with just the core band. It goes down pretty well”.

“We didn’t perform it back in the day. We mimed to it once. That was an odd one. We did a mime show with all of us acting the various characters. I was cast as Sorrow’s dad I think and my soon to be wife was Mrs Sorrow. We never performed the whole thing but we did songs from it”.

The original album was produced by Norman Smith who in the 70s had his own fame as Hurricane Smith and the hits ‘Oh Babe What Would You Say’ and ‘Who Was It’. “He had hits in Australia,” Dick said. “To say that it was out of character for Norman, he was a very respectable middle-class looking guy. He was a glider pilot in the Second Word War. He was as straight as a dye in appearance and speech but he was very much into quite avant-guard music. He picked up on us when we sent demos to record companies. Norman heard this stuff and it was due to him we got signed to EMI”.

Pretty Things will tour Australia for the last time in October. Taylor is now 75, May 73. This is their last tour.

Fans in Melbourne will be treated to one complete performance of SF Sorrow on October 6.

The Pretty Things Australian Dates

October 3, Sydney, Factory Theatre
October 4, Brisbane, The Zoo
October 6, Melbourne, Thornbury Theatre (performing SF Sorrow)
October 7, Melbourne, Caravan Clun
October 10, Geelong, Barwon Club
October 12, Melbourne, The Tote
October 13, Adelaide, Fowlers Live
October 14, Perth, The Charles Hotel

The Pretty Things will tour Australia for David Roy Williams. Get tickets

For news as it happens follow Noise11 on Facebook

Noise11.com

Listen to the Noise11 Music News channel now at iHeartRadio

Related Posts

The Doors Live At Bakersfield
The Doors: Live in Bakersfield, August 21, 1970 — A Wild, Rare Live Release

The Doors’ newly issued Live in Bakersfield, August 21, 1970 is one of the most compelling live documents to surface from the band’s archives in years. Released on both CD and limited edition vinyl, the concert captures Jim Morrison, Ray Manzarek, Robby Krieger, and John Densmore in a unique and unpredictable setting.

18 hours ago
The Who, Pete Townshend. Photo by Ros O'Gorman
Pete Townshend: Reveling at 80 on Final Who Tour and Bold New Beginnings

London’s indefatigable rock sage Pete Townshend recently granted AARP The Magazine a deeply revealing interview, with the questioning prowess of Jim Sullivan guiding him through reflections on The Who’s swan song and his exhilarating future ahead.

2 days ago
The Beatles Anthology box 2025 vinyl edition
The Beatles’ Anthology 4 Announcement Splits Fans Between Celebration and Criticism

The Beatles’ world lit up on 21 August 2025 when Apple Corps confirmed what had long been whispered: Anthology 4will arrive this November as part of a deluxe 8-CD / 12-LP box set. For many, the announcement was nothing short of historic—a long-awaited continuation of the celebrated mid-’90s Anthology trilogy. But while excitement has been intense, the news has also stirred division among fans. Some see Anthology 4 as a fitting final chapter, while others accuse it of being an unnecessary cash-grab.

2 days ago
Rolling Stones No 2
Rolling Stones Songs That Have Never Been Performed Live

It is Sunday afternoon in Australia so just for a bit of fun, he is a list of all of the Rolling Stones have recorded but have never performed live.

3 days ago
The Beatles Anthology box 2025 vinyl edition
The Beatles Anthology 4 Tracklisting and All The Details of the 2025 Release Revealed

The tracklisting for The Beatles ‘Anthology 4’ has been revealed by The Beatles’ Apple Records. According to Apple, ‘Anthology 2025’ is the ultimate story of The Beatles, told through a unique album collection, 25th Anniversary book, and Disney+ series.

5 days ago
Neil Diamond performs in Melbourne at Rod Laver Arena on Tuesday 27 October 2015. Photo Ros O'Gorman
Neil Diamond Musical ‘A Beautiful Noise’ to Premiere Exclusively For Australia in Melbourne in August 2026

‘A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical’ is coming to Melbourne in August 2026.

6 days ago
The Beatles Anthology 4 tease
The Beatles Tease Anthology 4

The Beatles have dropped what can only be described as a clear placeholder across their website and socials, an animation tracing the outline of the Anthology albums, counting “1-2-3-4.” Fans are already convinced this is the long-awaited signal for Anthology 4.

7 days ago