Once Again The Death Of The CD Is Exaggerated - Noise11 Music News
Ed Sheeran Divide

Ed Sheeran Divide

Once Again The Death Of The CD Is Exaggerated

by Paul Cashmere on June 12, 2017

in News,Noise Pro

Once again stories about the death of the CD have been grossly exaggerated. A study of this week’s Australian Top 10 ARIA album chart by The Noise Network shows that most fans prefer the physical format over streams and downloads.

Three 40+ year old Top 10 artists, Pete Murray, The Beatles and Roger Waters, understandably generated a high percentage of physical sales. However, the format of choice for pop based Ed Sheeran and Harry Styles and alt-rock Alt-J and All Time Low fans was also the CD.

50% of purchasers for Ed Sheeran’s ‘divide’ album were for the CD/LP format last week. 30% bought the album as a download and only 20% of sales came from fans who streamed the album.

56% of Harry Styles fans bought the physical disc ahead of download (24%) and streams (18%). (ARIA started including streaming in its chart figures in May, 2017).

There was only one exception in the Top 10 in favour of streams. 52% of Kendrick Lamar ‘Damn’ sales were based on streaming, while CD was 26% and downloads 22%.

If we go back 15 years to when Napster was the thing, rap acts traditionally were the most pirated acts. It seems rap fans still loath paying music but will toss a few bucks Spotify’s way these days to get their music.

Ed Sheeran’s earlier 2014 album ‘X’ was mainly sold as a download (36%) followed by streams (35%) and 29% sold as a physical disc. The sales for the three-year old ‘X’ album were fuelled by his major tour announcement and were not a high volume stock in the Warner warehouse at the time of the announcement.

The telling factor in this breakdown is the figures for Alt-J and All Time Low. Both fan-bases sit within the 20-39 demographic yet both favour CD sales ahead of downloads and streams.

Here is how this weeks Australian Top 10 albums breaks down by format:

1. Ed Sheeran – divide

sales = 30% download, 20% stream, 50% CD

2. Halsey – Hopeless Fountain Kingdom

sales = 47% download, 15% streams, 38% CD

3. Pete Murray – Camacho

sales = 36% download, 2% streams, 62% CD

4. Alt-J – Relaxer

sales = 44% download, 10% streams, 46% CD

5. All Time Low – Last Young Renegade

sales = 34% download, 6% streams, 40% CD

6. The Beatles – Sgt Pepper

sales = 11% download, 2% streams, 83% CD

7. Roger Waters – Is This The Life We Really Want

sales = 20% download, 1% streams, 79% CD

8. Harry Styles – Harry Styles

sales = 24% download, 18% streams, 56% CD

9. Kendrick Lamar – Damn

sales = 22% download, 52% streams, 26% CD

10. Ed Sheeran – X

sales = 36% download, 35% streams, 29% CD

Noise11.com

Related Posts

ARIA Billboard Offical Charts
Streaming Charts And Streaming Fraud: Why Modern Music Rankings Cannot Be Compared To Any Previous Era

The debate over streaming fraud and passive listening has intensified as chart milestones continue to be compared with records established during the vinyl, cassette and CD eras. Industry studies, platform disclosures and independent audits now suggest that modern music charts measure a fundamentally different consumer activity than the charts that once tracked physical purchases, raising questions about whether meaningful comparisons can be made across generations.

June 2, 2026
The Rubens Share Reflective New Single Are You Getting High

The Rubens have returned with ‘Are You Getting High', a new single that sees the New South Wales band lean further into the introspective songwriting that has defined much of their recent work. Released as the follow-up to ‘Goanna', the track explores the uneasy emotional space that follows the end of a relationship, capturing the tension between acceptance and unresolved resentment.

May 29, 2026
ARIA Billboard Offical Charts
Why Streaming Charts Cannot Be Compared To The Physical Sales Era

by Paul Cashmere The modern music charts used by ARIA, Billboard and the UK's Official Charts Company now measure an entirely different form of consumer behaviour than the charts of the vinyl, cassette and CD eras. While chart headlines frequently compare contemporary streaming milestones with historical sales achievements, industry analysts increasingly acknowledge that the two systems are built on fundamentally incompatible metrics.

May 28, 2026
ARIA Hall of Fame 2026
ARIA Hall Of Fame 2026 Inductees Signal Progress, But Heritage Gap Remains

Gurrumul, Jenny Morris, Kate Ceberano, Spiderbait, The Living End And Vika & Linda Headline ARIA Hall Of Fame 2026 Intake As Industry Eyes Long Overdue Recognition For Heritage Acts

May 3, 2026
Pink I'm Not Dead 20th Anniversary Album Cover Art
Pink Celebrates 20 Years Of I’m Not Dead The Album That Defined Her Career

Pink redefined her musical identity two decades ago with the release of the groundbreaking I'm Not Dead.

April 4, 2026
APRA photo by Samantha Quintal
Australian Creator Groups Unite Against Copyright Expansion Push

A coalition of Australian creator organisations including APRA AMCOS and ARIA has warned that proposed changes driven by the education sector could significantly erode the income of artists, writers and musicians.

March 21, 2026
ARIA charts
ARIA Charts Under Fire As Radio Proves It Is Still Carrying Australian Artists

ARIA has again pointed the finger at commercial radio while the only Australian song in the current ARIA Top 40 belongs to Tame Impala, raising fresh questions about how the charts are compiled and who is really supporting local music.

February 10, 2026