Justin Bieber's Paparazzo Court Case Thrown Out - Noise11.com
Justin Bieber, Noise11, Photo

Justin Bieber

Justin Bieber’s Paparazzo Court Case Thrown Out

by Claire Hennekam on November 15, 2012

in News

The case against photographer Paul Raef, who was the first person prosecuted under a new Californian law targeted at overly zealous paparazzi, has been thrown out of court this week, with the judge labelling the new law “problematic” and “overly inclusive”.

Justin Bieber image

Justin Bieber

In 2010, a new law was introduced in California, criminalising dangerous driving when taking photos commercially.

However, the law had not been tested until July this year, when Paul Raef, 30, was charged with two counts of violating the new law, following an incident on July 6th involving teen pop idol, Justin Bieber.

All up, the City Attorney’s office filed four misdemeanour charges against Raef at the time, including reckless driving with the intent to capture pictures for commercial gain, following another vehicle too closely, reckless driving and failure to obey a peace officer.

However, the first two counts were dismissed by Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Thomas Robinson on Wednesday who, according to Reuters, called the state’s anti-paparazzi law “problematic” and “overly inclusive.”

He made reference to law’s vague definition of commercial photography, which could inadvertently increase penalties for reckless driving, such as in the case of a photographer who was simply speeding to reach an arranged photo shoot with Bieber, meaning that they could potentially be charged with additional misdemeanours simply because of their profession.

For his part, Justin Bieber received a speeding ticket on the day in question when he was pulled over by police for driving 80 miles per hour in a 65 mph zone.

Telling officers at the time that he was being hounded by paparazzi, he called the police about 30 minutes later when Raef continued to follow him.

Paul Raef will be tried on the two remaining charges of reckless driving and failure to obey a peace officer at a later date and still faces the potential of six months in county jail.

Related Posts

Colin Hay performs at the Recital Centre in Melbourne on 11 February 2018. Photo by Ros O'Gorman
Ringo Starr Beams Down To Australia’s APRA Awards to Congratulate Colin Hay

Ringo Starr popped up at the APRA Awards in Sydney tonight to congratulate his friend Colin Hay on receiving the Ted Albert Award for Outstanding Services to Australian Music.

April 27, 2023
Justin Bieber, Photo By Ros O'Gorman
Justin Bieber Appears At Rolling Loud Festival

Justin Bieber made a surprise appearance at the Rolling Loud music festival in California on Saturday (04.03.23).

March 7, 2023
Justin Bieber in Sydney
Justin Bieber $ells Catalogue for Big Buck$

Justin Bieber has sold his entire music catalogue to Hipgnosis Songs Capital for a reported $200 million (£162 million).

January 26, 2023
Justin-Bieber-performs-at-Cockatoo-Island-photo-by-Ros-OGorman
Justin Bieber Cancels All Upcoming Tour Dates To Focus On Health

Justin Bieber has postponed the remaining dates of his Justice World Tour to focus on his health.

September 7, 2022
Justin Bieber in Sydney
Justin Bieber Back Working After Health Scare

Justin Bieber is feeling "grateful to be back" on his Justice World Tour after taking a break due to a facial paralysis scare.

August 2, 2022
Justin-Bieber-performs-at-Cockatoo-Island-photo-by-Ros-OGorman
Justin Bieber To Resume World Tour

Justin Bieber is to resume his Justice World Tour following a health scare earlier this year.

July 20, 2022
Justin Bieber, Photo By Ros O'Gorman
Justin Bieber Updates Fans With Video Of His Ramsay Hunt Syndrome Situation

Justin Bieber has shared with his fans news that he has Ramsay Hunt Syndrome.

June 11, 2022