Natalie Bassingthwaighte Struggles To Give Shirley Valentine Momentum #REVIEW - Noise11.com
Natalie Bassingthwaighte as Shirley Valentine

Natalie Bassingthwaighte as Shirley Valentine

Natalie Bassingthwaighte Struggles To Give Shirley Valentine Momentum #REVIEW

by Paul Cashmere on February 1, 2025

in News

Natalie Bassingthwaighte has taken on an enormous task with this One Person show ‘Shirley Valentine’ where she not only plays the lead (and only) role but she also has to conjure the other characters that are in the movie but absence from the stage as to their relevance to the plot.

‘Shirley Valentine’ is about a bored Liverpudlian housewife who goes to Greece, has a fling and decides to stay and start a new life.

In the 1989 movie, numerous actors play the various characters which gives context to the story. With one actor, Natalie Bassingthwaighte as Shirley Valentine, has too much focus on her character. It difficult for the audience to comprehend the bigger picture of the original story if you haven’t seen the move and it stretches the talents of Bassingthwaighte to and past her limits. Complete scenes in the movie have been reduced to dialogue for the play so be prepared to enact your theatre of the mind.

There are only two scenes. In act one it is the kitchen where Shirley’s conversation is mostly directed to the wall and in act two, Greece, where Shirley talks to a rock.

In all fairness to Natalie, this part is a major task for any actor. Remembering all of this dialogue with no other actors to bounce off is a difficult task for anyone. Natalie has taken on a difficult job with this play and the risk for the producers is that just one actor has to convince an entire audience night after night about authenticity.

Natalie often fell over her lines, forgot some words, left gaps and started anew. Let’s put that down to opening night jitters. But even in a perfectly executed performance I feel this show would be like watching paint dry.

The 1989 movie is a classic. At the time of its release this British rom-com-drama mixed a not often spoken about real life situation with the funny side of life. Pauline Collins pulled off a perfect comedic but serious Shirley. Natalie does not. The movie had a warmth, the play has a sadness to it. The movie was right for the time. The play would have been better served portraying the modern woman, not the modern woman’s mother.

The originally story accurately portrayed a common life of 1989. This story is still set in 1989 but the times have moved on and I’m not even sure a 42 year old from then in 1989 would now identify with this character today. Afterall, Shirley Valentine in 2025 would be 78 years old now. Maybe a 78-year old plus demographic might get this production.

Shirley Valentine has a limited run until 16 February 2025 at the Atheneum Theatre in Collins St, Melbourne.

Stay updated with your free Noise11.com daily music news email alert. Subscribe to Noise11 Music News here

Be the first to see NOISE11.com’s newest interviews and special features on YOUTUBE and updated regularly. See things first SUBSCRIBE here: Noise11 on YouTube SUBSCRIBE

Noise11.com

Noise11 is now on Bluesky. Follow us at

Related Posts

Pete Murray by Ian Laidlaw
Pete Murray Premieres New Song ‘Home To Me’

Pete Murray has shared a new song ‘Home To Me’.

2 days ago
Peter O'Doherty of Dog Trumpet
Peter O’Doherty’s ‘High On the Rocks’ Is The Latest Preview of Dog Trumpet’s ‘Live Forever’ Album

Dog Trumpet have premiered another preview of the upcoming ‘Live Forever’ album. ‘High On The Rocks’ is a Peter O’Doherty song.

3 days ago
Atomic The Songs Of Blondie
Victor Stranges Has Another Black Market Clash and Songs of Blondie Show

Victor Stranges will once again perform the music of The Clash and Blondie in a Black Market Clash and The Songs of Blondie show scheduled for Belgrave, outside Melbourne on June 22.

3 days ago
Bleak Squad by Felix Oliver
Check Out Bleak Squad Melbourne’s New Indie Supergroup

The debut album from Bleak Squad is coming in August. Who, you ask? Bleak Squad is a new Melbourne indie rock supergroup featuring Mick Turner (Dirty Three, Mess Esque), Mick Harvey (Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds, PJ Harvey, The Birthday Party), Adalita (Magic Dirt) and Marty Brown (Art of Fighting).

4 days ago
Hank Marvin's Gypsy Jazz
Hank Marvin’s Gypsy Jazz To Play Two Shows In Perth

Hank Marvin Gypsy Jazz is playing occasional shows in 2025 with Perth just announced for two September shows.

4 days ago
Fred Loneragan Machinations 1984
Fred Loneragan Doesn’t Rule Out A Fourth Machinations Album

In the 1980s, Machinations released three albums ‘Esteem’ (1983), ‘Big Music’ (1985) and ‘Uptown’ (1988). Singer and co-founder Fred Loneragan isn’t ruling out the possibility of a long overdue fourth album for 2026.

4 days ago
Sly Stone
Leo Sayer Shares His Thoughts on The Passing of Sly Stone

There really is a riot going on right now, so what a poignant moment it seems to be to lose a hero I never met, yet a man I often imagined as my soul brother. I worked with many of his alumni (including the man who helped invent him, fellow San Fran disk jockey Tom Donahue), and to say they and he inspired me would be a useless understatement.

6 days ago