Rolling Stone Readers Pick Their Top Ten Heavy Metal Albums - Noise11.com
Metallica Master of Puppets

Metallica Master of Puppets

Rolling Stone Readers Pick Their Top Ten Heavy Metal Albums

by Roger Wink, VVN Music on September 20, 2012

in News

Last Friday, Rolling Stone asked their on-line readers to select what they thought were the greatest heavy metal albums of all-time.

Metallica Master of Puppets

Metallica Master of Puppets

Of course, actually defining what is heavy metal and what isn’t is a bit of a problem.

Obviously, Metallica, who has four of the top ten, and Black Sabbath, who score two, are the epitome of heavy metal. Iron Maiden and Slayer could also fall into that category, but Guns N’ Roses? Are they really metal or just an all-out hard rock band?

And then there is the case of Led Zeppelin. They’re blues-rock, hard rock, rock-and-roll, but can they really be considered heavy metal?

So, here are the ten albums that the readers considered heavy metal and considered great, but maybe they aren’t all great heavy metal.

  1. Master of Puppets – Metallica
  2. Paranoid – Black Sabbath
  3. Black Sabbath – Black Sabbath
  4. The Number of the Beast – Iron Maiden
  5. …And Justice For All – Metallica
  6. Reign in Blood – Slayer
  7. Appetite For Destruction – Guns N’ Roses
  8. Metallica (Black Album) – Metallica
  9. Led Zeppelin II – Led Zeppelin
  10. Ride the Lightning – Metallica

Related Posts

Templeton Pek announce new album Savages out 3 October 2025
Templeton Pek Fly the Flag for Birmingham Punk With Ferocious New Album ‘Savages’

Birmingham's own punk rock power trio Templeton Pek are charging back into the spotlight with their new album Savages. The record marks a defiant new chapter for the long-running UK punk outfit, a band forged in the same industrial heartland that gave the world Black Sabbath, Judas Priest, Duran Duran, and The Streets.

October 5, 2025
Ozzy Osbourne and Judas Priest release charity version of Black Sabbath’s War Pigs.
Judas Priest and Ozzy Osbourne Unite For Charity Version of Black Sabbath’s ‘War Pigs’

Heavy metal has always thrived on moments that defy expectation, and today one of the genre's most historic collaborations has landed. Shortly before his death, Ozzy Osbourne teamed with fellow British metal pioneers Judas Priest for a brand-new charity version of Black Sabbath's immortal classic War Pigs.

September 28, 2025
Aerosmith and Yungblud promo pic
Aerosmith and Yungblud Team for New EP ‘One More Time’

Aerosmith have returned with their first new music in more than a decade, teaming up with British rocker Yungblud for a collaborative five-track EP titled One More Time. The release is set for 21 November 2025, with the lead single My Only Angel available today.

September 19, 2025
Ozzy Osbourne Black Sabbath photo by Ros O'Gorman
Aerosmith, Yungblud and Nuno Bettencourt Lead Ozzy Osbourne Tribute at MTV VMAs

The 2025 MTV Video Music Awards became a night of rock remembrance when the late Ozzy Osbourne was honoured with a powerhouse tribute led by Aerosmith legends Steven Tyler and Joe Perry.

September 8, 2025
Roger Waters talking at an event for Australia Palestine Advocacy Network (APAN) at the Atheneum Theatre Melbourne on Friday 9 February 2018. Photo Ros O'Gorman
Bitter and Twisted Roger Waters Gets Even More Twisted Over Ozzy Osbourne

Jack Osbourne, son of Black Sabbath legend the late Ozzy Osbourne, had this to say to former Pink Floyd member Roger Waters. “F*ck You”.

September 3, 2025
Deep Purple: Photo By Ros O'Gorman
Legendary Deep Purple Voice Turns 80: Ian Gillan’s Journey Through Sound, Loss, and Legacy

Ian Gillan, the iconic vocalist of Deep Purple, celebrates his 80th birthday (19 August 2025). Still blessed with a powerful, wide-ranging voice—even into his eighth decade—Gillan has traversed the peaks and troughs of rock history with a rare grace and tenacity.

August 20, 2025
Ozzy Osbourne and Black Sabbath photo by Ros OGorman
Ozzy Osbourne Fans Turn Out In The Thousands For Funeral Procession

Ozzy Osbourne's wife and children were overcome with emotion as they visited the vast sea of tributes to the rocker during the funeral procession in Birmingham, England on Wednesday.

July 31, 2025